Wednesday, May 17, 2006

Drowning

I went to my first ever Human Rights Film Festival movie, Drowned Out, tonite with the Powell's, Ritchie's & Read's.

This movie highlighted an issue that not many of us in the developed world know about. It's about the dams that have been & are being built on the River Narmada in India and how the lives of so many are affected by this seemingly well intentioned project. (In my very humble opinion, this project is centered around ego, pride, greed, supposed honour & glory for the nation.)

For dams to be built, all living along the river are affected. Those living up stream loose their land, livelihood, homes etc due to flooding. Those down stream loose the same due to 'drought'. These people are not compensated appropriately, either offered resettlement land that is measly in comparison to what they had or cash, which is of not much use to them because they depend on the land. Some are driven to the city to survive and end up living in slumps on the outskirts of the city earning next to nothing and just barely surviving and others end up dying defending their land by refusing to leave.

When the villager make the tiring journey to the nearest township to try and get answers or fight for their land, there is little luck. The official has either been transferred, sacked, replaced, not around. Either way the journey was for nothing.

This is still an on going issue. For regular updates, click here.

For me, this is nothing new; all the political bullshit, empty promises. I grew up in a country that had all of that. And that is one of the many reasons why my parents decided to relocate to a better, fairer country. But I was still frustrated and pissed off.

Why is it ok for the poor to suffer in order for the rich to live 'better' lives but not ok when the equation is the other way round? Why is there so much hypocrisy? So much greed? So much pride? WHY?

4 comments:

Geekery said...

"In my very humble opinion, this project is centered around ego, pride, greed, supposed honour & glory for the nation."

Yep, thats about right. Hit the nail on the head.

Funny thing is it's only the rich that seem to have this ego.

The other thing that hit me with the film was that these people wern't just loosing their homes - they were loosing everything - their entire physical and spiritual lives were being destroyed. Their souls were being ripped out and left to dorwn in the river whilst empty shells were moved to the slums.

jeanie said...

Yea...

Just another addition to the end of the post:

It's not only the poor, but the minority that are forced to sacrifice all they know so that the majority can benefit.

For me, that's the frustrating bit coz that's exactly what was happening to us in M'sia. The chinese aren't that small in number but it was always ahveing to put up with the developments that were supposedly for all but it was actually meant for the Muslims and other indigenous groups.

jeanie said...

We've got Sky too and it's so much better to be getting CNN, BBC, Sky News....

I much prefer the way in which NZ new is presented but I don't like the lack of news that is being put across. Where as in M'sia, even though I cannot stand the new readers, at least we hear a bit more about what is happening aroundn the world.

Funny how developed countries go on about wanting to help developing countries but at the same time suppress the truth...

BJ said...

Thanks for the review - I didn't manage to organise myself to go - so I'm glad to get the low down.